8 minute read

Addressing the Root Causes of Maternal Health Inequity

Foundational steps for clinical leaders


What you'll learn

The United States is the only industrialized nation where maternal mortality and morbidity rates are increasing. All U.S. demographic groups experience an elevated risk of adverse outcomes, but Black and Native American patients experience devastating rates of complications. Clinical leaders can advance equitable outcomes by embedding best practice obstetrics protocols into frontline practice, tracking performance and identifying care gaps, and tapping into system- and community-based resources.


The conventional wisdom

Most hospitals and health systems have made significant investments in maternal health. Those investments often include creating point-of-delivery care standards and emergency protocols for labor and delivery. This focus on labor and delivery—while mission-critical—solves only part of the challenge. In fact, 64% of pregnancy-related deaths occur during pregnancy and between one week and one year postpartum, also known as the “fourth trimester.” That is because inadequate access to prenatal and postpartum care leaves many patients at increased risk for clinical escalation and long-term complications.

Additionally, conventional efforts to reduce maternal morbidity and mortality operate mostly “colorblind,” without investments designed specifically to support the most at-risk racial groups. Similarly, quality reporting regulations do not require health care organizations to track or publish maternal health outcomes by race.

Timing distribution of pregnancy-related deaths

Our take

To adequately improve outcomes, clinical leaders must understand the root causes of health disparities and take appropriate actions at the system level.

Maternal health interventions are incomplete without addressing racial health disparities. That is because the U.S. maternal health crisis is, at its core, a crisis of inequity. Although all demographics are impacted by the poor performance of the U.S. in maternal health compared with other industrialized nations, women of color are disproportionately impacted. The pregnancy-related mortality rate for Black patients in the US is 3.3x the rate for white patients. For Native American patients, it’s 2.5x the rate. These trends are similar for morbidity rates. To improve outcomes, health care organizations must examine the root causes of inequities: the intersection of structural racism and sexism.

Root causes of maternal health disparities

1. Enduring legacies of institutional racism hardwired into policy, social institutions, and culture

2. Deprioritization of women's holistic health care across the life span, particularly in favor of fetal outcomes

Without an in-depth understanding of how these root causes manifest, interventions aren’t likely to make a significant or sustained impact.

The legacies of these structural underpinnings impact women of color across four levels: systemic, institutional, interpersonal, and individual.

These multifaceted and interconnected inequities are deeply embedded within the U.S. health care system. That’s why true change is so challenging. Hospitals cannot solve structural racism and sexism on their own, but they do have a role to play in reducing maternal health inequities.

The four ways inequities manifest in maternal health

Three steps to improve maternal health

Clinical executives are uniquely positioned to champion maternal health equity investments at their organization. While investments should focus on addressing the needs of the most at-risk populations—Black and Native American patients—these changes will improve health outcomes for all maternal patients.

There are three immediate steps that hospitals and health systems can take to improve maternal health equity. First, all organizations should make best practice obstetrics protocols easy for frontline staff to implement. Then, organizations should institute ongoing feedback mechanisms to monitor adherence to care standards and assess gaps in maternal care. With that intel in hand, champions should tap into resources outside their traditional purview to expand their impact.

All organizations should ensure their obstetrics patients receive the highest quality, evidence-based care throughout their delivery. To do this, organizations must ensure that staff are aware of best practices and can easily follow them.

Adopting evidence-based care standards

Organizations must start with adopting best practice safety protocols if they haven’t already. The Alliance for Innovation on Maternal Health (AIM) has developed open-access, data-driven maternal safety bundles for hospitals and health systems to adopt, including bundles on:

  • Depression and anxiety
  • Maternal venous thromboembolism
  • Obstetric care for women with opioid use disorder
  • Obstetric hemorrhage
  • Postpartum care basics
  • Prevention of retained vaginal sponges after birth
  • Severe hypertension in pregnancy
  • Reduction of peripartum racial/ethnic disparities
  • Safe reduction of primary cesarean birth

To review these protocols, visit the Council on Patient Safety in Women’s Health Care here.

Facilitating frontline implementation

After reviewing evidence-based safety protocols, leaders must ensure clinicians are able to easily and consistently incorporate them into workflows. To do so, engage a multidisciplinary group of leaders, including physician, nursing, and administration, to design and roll out care standards system-wide.

Maternal health champions should:

  • Use simulation training to prepare care teams for rare, severe, and timesensitive complications. Hold training sessions to unearth unanticipated barriers to protocol implementation. Then, engage the team in brainstorming how to address them. Emphasize that emergency communication procedures are evidence-based and must be as regimented as clinical procedures.
  • Hardwire channels for regular intra- and inter-team communication to keep everyone accountable for sharing timely information. Schedule regular meetings for leaders to update staff on new programs or educational materials. Publish provider adherence data and highlight the impact of protocol changes to encourage behavior change.

It can be deeply unsettling for frontline care teams to hear that their practice could lead to unnecessary maternal death—or worse, that is already has. It’s likely that you’ll face pushback rooted in these difficult emotions, as well as general resistance to logistical change. To overcome these barriers, approach conversations with care teams, departments, and facilities as equal partnerships and identify the structural—not individual—challenges to ensuring patient safety.

For more guidance on designing easy-to-implement care standards, review our Create Care Standards Your Front Line Will Embrace research report.

Once organizations have no-regrets safety protocols in place, maternal health champions should institute ongoing feedback mechanisms to monitor adherence to care standards and identify other gaps in maternal care. Champions should:

  • Expand maternal mortality review boards to become multidisciplinary perinatal review committees
  • Use race-stratified data and community input to identify and address care gaps

Expand existing maternal mortality review boards into multidisciplinary perinatal review committees

The first step is to launch a multidisciplinary perinatal review committee to unearth the root causes of clinical escalation. Many organizations already have maternal mortality review boards, but these should be expanded beyond instances of mortality during delivery to include all complications before, during, and after birth. This expanded charter emphasizes that it’s important to prevent “near misses” as well as mortality, since morbidities can lead to long-term health complications and emotional trauma. Reviewing all unexpected complications, no matter the outcome, also ensures that successful responses to these complications are a matter of planned processes, not luck.

Committees should be made up of a truly multidisciplinary group, including a range of clinical and administrative leaders as well as patients and community members. A wide perspective allows the committee to use a broad definition of morbidities. It should include clinical complications, downstream mental health impacts, and subjective measures including whether patients felt respected and were owners in the medical decision-making.

Use race-stratified data and community input to identify and address care gaps

Multidisciplinary perinatal reviews surface critical gaps in care delivery after a serious complication has occurred. In addition to these reactive improvements, leaders should task data analysts and community health staff with collecting quantitative and qualitative data to proactively identify blind spots and next steps.

Common metrics to track, stratified by race, include:

  • Number of prenatal care appointments
  • Number of postpartum care appointments
  • Self-reported patient satisfaction
  • Social needs

Three tips for designing an effective data-gathering strategyThree tips for designing an effective data-gathering strategy

With this intel in hand, clinical leaders should make targeted investments by tapping into resources outside their traditional purview: across the system and in the community. Design solutions in partnership with the most impacted groups to advance equity. Prioritize partnerships that achieve the following:

  • Connect community health leaders with frontline staff to offer ongoing cultural humility and clinical training. Cultural humility training must cover topics of power and privilege, structural inequities, and how injustice manifests in health care. Implicit bias training is an important first step, but education should extend to how staff can identify their own biases and mitigate them using patient engagement tactics. Demonstrate how staff can fit tactics into their workflows and make the most of limited time with patients. In addition, leaders should offer clinical education to dispel misconceptions that lead to disparate care (for example, the fallacy that Black people have thicker skin).
  • Normalize and refer patients to perinatal-specific behavioral health care. Patients can experience a range of behavioral health challenges before and after delivery, including anxiety, depression, hypomania, and substance use. Many patients are only familiar with postpartum depression and may feel shame for not adhering to societal expectations of motherhood. Staff should screen for behavioral health needs during and after the pregnancy to normalize perinatal mood disorders and connect patients to care before severe escalations. Care should be perinatal- specific, including a specialized focus on building confidence in parenting skills, identifying support networks, and supporting infant bonding.
  • Proactively identify and address social needs by connecting patients to community partners. As with any condition, a patient’s social needs before and after the pregnancy can reduce access to care, interfere with selfmanagement behaviors, and cause significant stress. Comprehensive prenatal and postpartum care must include social support to overcome barriers around food, housing, transportation, financial stability, and more. Community health workers can help unearth and address these needs by building trusting relationships and connecting patients with community-based organizations and social services.
  • Partner with midwifery and doula groups to integrate additional patientcentered support into the care team. Some hospitals and health systems have employed midwives, but few have doulas. Both types of staff can help serve as a patient’s advocate throughout the pregnancy and delivery. Increasing evidence indicates that midwives and doulas can have a significantly positive impact on health outcomes and patient satisfaction. Contract with community-based midwifery and doula groups to support patients at highest risk of complications, including Black and Native American patients. Ensure these staff can easily enter care settings and have access to the patient during the delivery.
  • Invest in telehealth capabilities to extend the care team’s reach to patients who face access barriers—particularly those in rural settings Geographic spread, the cost of transportation, and reduced wages from missed work reduces patients’ ability to come to frequent obstetric appointments. Tele-visits and outpatient remote monitoring can help overcome access barriers and mitigate patient risk. In rural areas, some providers may help relocate high-risk patients in their third trimester to a maternity home or other short-term housing to be closer to specialty care upon delivery.

Parting thoughts

The root causes of the U.S. maternal health equity crisis are complex and overwhelming, and the changes needed to reverse current trends will not be easy. But this is not the job of a clinical leader—or hospital, for that matter—alone. Success requires multidisciplinary, community-based action.

However, action shouldn’t be restricted to hospital/community partnerships. The most effective way to address the root causes of inequities is through government policy change. Hospitals and health systems already have policy advocacy efforts traditionally targeted at reimbursement rates, as well as the clout and scale to be effective. Leaders should direct resources to support government proposals designed to improve maternal access to care, quality outcomes, and workplace equity. Major proposals include:

  • Extend Medicaid coverage and increase Medicaid reimbursement
  • Improve funding and reimbursement rates for nontraditional providers
  • Offer pregnancy bundle payments
  • Introduce additional quality measures
  • Secure equitable leave for all parents
  • Reduce pregnancy discrimination in the workplace

To support hospital initiatives, Advisory Board will continue to identify tactical examples hospitals and health systems can implement to improve performance and advance equitable outcomes. For more on this public health crisis, review our Snapshot of Maternal Health Inequity cheat sheet.


SPONSORED BY

INTENDED AUDIENCE

AFTER YOU READ THIS

AUTHORS

Darby Sullivan

Director, Health equity research

TOPICS

INDUSTRY SECTORS

Don't miss out on the latest Advisory Board insights

Create your free account to access 1 resource, including the latest research and webinars.

Want access without creating an account?

   

You have 1 free members-only resource remaining this month.

1 free members-only resources remaining

1 free members-only resources remaining

You've reached your limit of free insights

Become a member to access all of Advisory Board's resources, events, and experts

Never miss out on the latest innovative health care content tailored to you.

Benefits include:

Unlimited access to research and resources
Member-only access to events and trainings
Expert-led consultation and facilitation
The latest content delivered to your inbox

You've reached your limit of free insights

Become a member to access all of Advisory Board's resources, events, and experts

Never miss out on the latest innovative health care content tailored to you.

Benefits include:

Unlimited access to research and resources
Member-only access to events and trainings
Expert-led consultation and facilitation
The latest content delivered to your inbox

This content is available through your Curated Research partnership with Advisory Board. Click on ‘view this resource’ to read the full piece

Email ask@advisory.com to learn more

Click on ‘Become a Member’ to learn about the benefits of a Full-Access partnership with Advisory Board

Never miss out on the latest innovative health care content tailored to you. 

Benefits Include:

Unlimited access to research and resources
Member-only access to events and trainings
Expert-led consultation and facilitation
The latest content delivered to your inbox

This is for members only. Learn more.

Click on ‘Become a Member’ to learn about the benefits of a Full-Access partnership with Advisory Board

Never miss out on the latest innovative health care content tailored to you. 

Benefits Include:

Unlimited access to research and resources
Member-only access to events and trainings
Expert-led consultation and facilitation
The latest content delivered to your inbox
AB
Thank you! Your updates have been made successfully.
Oh no! There was a problem with your request.
Error in form submission. Please try again.